For all of the incredible stuff that the movies have produced, radically shifting how we view, interact and understand our world and respective cultures there are still things that films genuinely struggle to portray well – one of the most prevalent being mental illness. It turns out that trying to represent complex, subjective things can be really quite difficult, especially when they don’t translate well to the language of cinema. It isn’t easy to portray the complex, often abstract language of someone’s inner mental and emotional life without being overly reductive so when a film manages to do so well, it’s something that should be celebrated.
As a preemptive defense I should say that the film does still feature a quirky romance, a couple of attractive leads and an older respected actor holding down the supporting cast role but it does genuinely try to engage with complicated issues around mental health. It’s garnered quite a cult following and proves that the good looking lead might just have some serious talent as an actor in provocative material.
I SEEM TO HAVE PUT THE WRONG FILM HERE
Oh, alright I’m being a little facetious but this is all by way of perspective. Silver Linings Playbook is a good film, a refreshing look at personal problems and a genuinely outstanding performance from Jennifer Lawrence. The film follows Bradley Cooper playing Pat, a man with bi-polar disorder who is released from a psychiatric hospital after forming a close friendship with Danny (Chris Tucker! Playing the comedy relief character? WHATEVER NEXT) Pat moves back home, determined to get his life back together and reunite with his estranged wife. Through a friend he s introduced to the recently widowed Tiffany Maxwell (played by Lawrence) and the two develop an odd friendship due to their respective weird neuroses.
She offers her services as go between for Pat and Nikki as long as Pat will partner her in an upcoming dance competition. Pat ends up getting a typed letter from Nikki that drops hints that maybe the two of them could get back together. As Pat and Tiffany grow closer Pat’s father gets into gambling trouble after some bad bets at a football game and needs his son to score well at the competition to get him out of trouble. The only way Pat Snr and Tiffany persuade Pat to dance is by telling him that Nikki will be there at the contest. The twist is that Nikki never wrote the letter – Tiffany did, and of course, she shows up at the contest any way. Thankfully it ends up all coming out OK as Pat realises that he doesn’t want to get back together because he is love with Tiffany.
And they all lived happily ever after.
If there is anything that the film shows it is the potential of the individual, and here I am not referring to the cast, (as excellent as they are.) The film works solely because of the involvement of director and writer David O. Russell. He’s somewhat of an odd duck in American cinema, with the ability to pull together strong and interesting films – “quirky” but without the negative connotations that word deservedly carries. He’s gained a reputation as a bit of a hot head too, getting into arguments and fights during at least two of his films.
That said it’s the screenplay that makes this work and the direction adds the shine. Yes, the leads are charming but they behave precisely how they SHOULD behave because they are leads in a screwy rom-com. Thanks to the quality of the writing and directing this isn’t that noticeable as Russell manages to keep the film dancing the fine line between bittersweet and romantic.
So, did it deserve its Oscar win? Tough to say really and whether Jennifer Lawrence is really the best actress of the year, based on this film alone, is a genuinely close call. She’s unmistakably a serious acting talent but I would like to see her in more challenging and interesting roles as here all she needs to do is be charming and sort of kooky (Zooey Deschanel should be worried…) Added to that the fact she has managed to get the internet to fall in love with her and a star was deservedly born when she won. It might sound like I’m not giving the film enough credit but what I do like is that this is a film that manages to tackle things like mental and marital breakdown, football and romance with deft writing and great direction.
Russell has always had an interest for trying to combine blockbuster mentality with interesting ideas and he is the only film-maker I know of who would try and make an ‘existential comedy.’ That said, I don’t think this is the best thing he could do. Which means that even when he hasn’t hit his stride yet he still manages to win Oscars.
That’s actually kind of impressive…
- Film Watch – 306. Silver Linings Playbook (mrschristine.com)
- Holden author says Oscar win is surreal (boston.com)
- My Choice for Best Director Oscar 2013 (Having Seen & Reviewed All 5 Films) : Michael Haneke For Amour (sashankkini.wordpress.com)
- Silver Linings Playbook Review (moviereviewbyyou.wordpress.com)